Sony WH-1000XM5 vs. Bose QuietComfort Ultra: A Listening-Room Test
The two flagships everyone asks about. We ran them through our 14-microphone listening rig, four months of daily commutes, and a transatlantic flight. Different headphones, different winners.
Sony for travel and noise cancellation; Bose for music and call quality.
+ What we liked
- ✓Sony's noise cancellation is still best-in-class for jet engines
- ✓Bose's Immersive Audio is genuinely impressive (the rare 'spatial' that earns it)
- ✓Both have 30+ hour battery in real use
− What could be better
- !Sony's touch controls are hit-or-miss in cold weather
- !Bose's mic isn't as good for calls
Of all the headphone questions our readers send, this is the most-asked. After four months of daily duty in a real listening room, on real commutes, and on one transatlantic flight, here's the answer.
The listening rig
- Calibrated 14-mic listening room (we measure frequency response on a HATS dummy head).
- Real-world: 60 days of daily commute use, plus one transatlantic flight.
- Call-quality test: identical scripted call on the same network with each pair.
- Long-term: comfort assessment after 4-hour wear sessions.
Sony WH-1000XM5
Best-in-class active noise cancellation, particularly in the 30–200 Hz range where jet engines and HVAC live. Battery life is the longest in the category — 30+ hours real use. The microphone for calls is good. The touch controls on the right cup are sometimes finicky in cold weather.
Bose QuietComfort Ultra
The Immersive Audio mode is the rare "spatial audio" feature that meaningfully improves listening — particularly for podcasts and live recordings. The fit is a touch more comfortable for our long-session testers. Mic for calls is the weak point.
The verdict
If your primary use is travel — flights, trains, noisy commutes — the Sony is the right call. The noise cancellation in the low-frequency range is decisively better. If your primary use is music and you take calls daily, the Bose is the better all-around pick.
What our readers said
- Lin J.Sep 30, 2025, 3:33 PM
Bought ours four months ago. Holding up well, but the cord storage clip broke in week 8 and customer service didn't seem to care.
- Kyle T.Oct 1, 2025, 1:50 AM
Good honest review. The 'we don't recommend' section is the part I trust the most — most reviews can't bring themselves to be negative about anything.
- Drew L.Oct 2, 2025, 5:07 AM
Reading this on a Saturday morning with my coffee. This is what subscription-supported reviews should look like.
- Ines M.Oct 3, 2025, 9:24 AM★★★★★
I came here to see if you'd address the dishwasher question and you did. Bought based on that detail alone. Thanks.
- Tabitha S.Oct 4, 2025, 1:41 PM
Long-term update: nine months in, still going strong. Wish more reviews followed up at the 12-month mark.
- Beatrice E.Oct 5, 2025, 5:58 PM
Three months of ownership. The 'set and forget' aspect is real — I genuinely don't think about this thing on a daily basis.
- Priya N.Oct 6, 2025, 3:15 AM
Year-and-a-half of ownership here. The button labels have worn off but otherwise it's been bulletproof.
More from Tech
See all →
The August Wave of 'Free Semester' App Trials, and the Fall Bill Behind It
Semester-length free trials on study apps are timed to convert right when attention is elsewhere. A pre-semester log habit keeps the fall bill from surprising you.
Why That Checkout Timer Keeps Resetting, and What It's Really Doing
That checkout clock ticking down may reset the moment you leave. How manufactured urgency short-circuits comparison shopping, and a simple test to defuse it.
Dark Patterns in Cancellation Flows: Why Signing Up Is Easy and Quitting Isn't
Signup takes one click; cancellation is often built to take much longer — here is how that friction works and the habits that get you out cleanly anyway.