Mr. Coffee vs. Bonavita: Which Drip Coffee Maker Earns Counter Space?
Two drip machines, three months, identical beans. The Bonavita brews demonstrably better coffee. The Mr. Coffee is one-fifth the price. Here's how to choose.
Bonavita if you care about flavor; Mr.
+ What we liked
- ✓Bonavita brews to SCA-spec temperature
- ✓Mr. Coffee is dirt-cheap and does the job for casual coffee drinkers
- ✓Both have machine-rinseable brew baskets
− What could be better
- !Mr. Coffee's water temperature is 8-10°F below ideal
- !Bonavita's flat-bottom basket is fussier to dial in
If you make drip coffee daily, here's the question: pay $200 for a real brew, or $40 for hot brown water? After three months, the answer is "depends on the drinker."
The Bonavita
Brews to the SCA standard temperature range (197.6–204°F) and holds it across the brew cycle. The flat-bottom basket gives a more even extraction than cone-shaped baskets. The result is meaningfully better coffee, particularly with mid-light roasts.
The Mr. Coffee
Brews 8–10°F below the SCA range. With darker roasts, this is fine — you cannot really taste the difference. With lighter or specialty roasts, the cup tastes underextracted, sour, and a little flat.
The bottom line
If you drink darker roasts and you don't fuss, Mr. Coffee. If you drink specialty single-origin and you care about extraction, Bonavita.
What our readers said
- Owen M.Mar 18, 2025, 5:21 AM
The methodology section was actually really helpful. Most reviews skip explaining how they tested.
- Iris L.Mar 19, 2025, 9:38 AM
Bought ours four months ago. Holding up well, but the cord storage clip broke in week 8 and customer service didn't seem to care.
- Nadia A.Mar 20, 2025, 1:55 PM
Good honest review. The 'we don't recommend' section is the part I trust the most — most reviews can't bring themselves to be negative about anything.
- Yuki S.Mar 20, 2025, 11:12 PM★★★★★
Reading this on a Saturday morning with my coffee. This is what subscription-supported reviews should look like.
- Jordan R.Mar 22, 2025, 3:29 AM
I came here to see if you'd address the dishwasher question and you did. Bought based on that detail alone. Thanks.
More from Kitchen
See all →The Ninja Creami: An Honest Take After 60 Days of Daily Use
TikTok wants you to buy a Ninja Creami. After 60 days and 38 pints of weird homemade ice cream, we have some opinions — most of them lukewarm.
The Best Espresso Machine Under $1,000 (After Pulling 2,400 Shots)
Eleven dual-boiler and single-boiler machines, nine months on the counter, roughly 2,400 shots pulled. One mid-priced unit kept making cafe-grade espresso when the others had given up.
The Best Electric Kettle for Most People (After Boiling 100 Liters)
Variable-temp kettles, gooseneck pour-overs, and one beautiful but pointless 'smart' kettle. The right kettle is the one that disappears into your morning.